Beware of Those Who Suggest You ‘Get Help’

A reader emails, “My family has been encouraging my brother to seek psychotherapy for problems we feel that he has, and his doctor agrees with us. My brother is resistant to that, and we can’t understand why he doesn’t see that he needs counseling to work through his issues. What can we do to help him?”

Well, Dear Reader, you can help him by getting off his back about therapy! You cannot “cure” someone who’s indifferent to a cure. The motivation for counseling has to come from the clients or patients themselves, not the family, the doctor, a judge or whomever. Medical conditions that can be healed with pills or surgery are not the same as mental or emotional issues. The psychotherapy “patients” have to be willing to challenge and change their errors in thinking, with the therapist as a coach or guide.

Sometimes the client/patient is not merely indifferent, but is actually hostile to therapy. Of course, the family may think, “Well, that’s OK. The therapist will fix him.” Wrong again. A person cannot have his beliefs changed FOR him. Beliefs and ideas can only be changed through thinking and reasoning methods. If in fact he does acknowledge something is wrong, then a therapist may be able to steer him toward correcting his errors in thinking. But it’s fantasy to expect that the mind can change without the willingness to think. This is the problem with today’s trend of applying a medical metaphor to psychotherapy. Reason and rationality are not surgery performed on an otherwise passive body; they can only be practiced by one who wants to practice them.

A common mistake made by parents, friends and even spouses is to assume that a person who has been self-destructive or self-defeating will immediately “listen to reason” the moment they encounter a psychotherapist. The loved one is certain that the therapist will say exactly what he or she thinks. This doesn’t always happen. For one thing, the loved one could be wrong. For another, the unwilling therapy patient/client won’t necessarily tell the therapist the whole truth. In fact, there’s absolutely no guarantee that he or she will even show up for the session.

Typically, the individual who is interested in therapy for another person will call the psychotherapist and say, “I want you to help my (whomever) with (whatever).” But why isn’t the other person calling on his or her own behalf? I always require the person whose therapy it is to schedule the appointment him- or herself. After all, if you’re not even invested enough to pick up the phone to schedule your own session, how can you be expected to do anything else to improve your life?

I want to offer a note of caution regarding this idea of “getting help.” When somebody claims, “I want to help you,” what they usually mean is, “I want to change you.” The whole thing is a disingenuous attempt to conceal an impossibility behind a possibility. In other words, the falsehood that one can change another person is thinly disguised behind the “feel-good” (and false) cliché that “helping” is always virtuous and therefore rational. Busybodies beware: One can only change oneself. Examine YOUR agenda, not theirs.

I’m always wary of the notion of somebody else trying to help or “rescue” you. Usually someone who wants to “help” is really more interested in control. If you truly care, you don’t control; you persuade. The art of persuasion has never been easy, but the principles are timeless. If you demonstrate that you care about someone before asking them to do something, they are more likely to trust your motives.

Not all human beings act rationally in all situations, but we are reasoning creatures nonetheless. We can be intimidated or forced to do things in the short term, but manipulation is never a substitute for persuasion. Only facts and logic can truly change people. Psychotherapy can be a magnificent tool in this regard, but it is no substitute for honestly stating and trying to prove your own conclusions – conclusions that you hope your loved one will reach as well.



Follow Dr. Hurd on Facebook. Search under “Michael Hurd” (Charleston SC). Get up-to-the-minute postings, recommended articles and links, and engage in back-and-forth discussion with Dr. Hurd on topics of interest. Also follow Dr. Hurd on Twitter at @MichaelJHurd1, drmichaelhurd on Instagram, Michael Hurd Ph.D. on LinkedIn, @DrHurd on TruthSocial


Why Get Help?

Solution-focused life coaching with Dr. Hurd